Senators do not know how Facebook works-CNN

Senators do not know how Facebook works-CNN

The U.S Congress doesn’t understand Facebook.

Mark Zuckerberg emerged unscathed from a Senate committee hearing, and he did so largely because most of the Senators who asked him questions had no clue how Facebook works.

They also did not seem to know what the solutions to its problems are, or even what they were trying to achieve by calling its CEO to testify, other than getting some good soundbites in.

What the first day of the Zuckerberg hearings made clear is that many American lawmakers are illiterate when it comes to 21st century technology.

As a result, the issue that was supposed to be the focus of the hearing — “social media privacy and the use and abuse of data,” as Sen. Chuck Grassley put it — was but one among many.

And at the moment when the country needed a smart conversation about privacy, what it got was meandering questions and misfires.

There were exceptions to the rule: most notably, California Sen. Kamala Harris, who pressed Zuckerberg on his failure to explain how extensively Facebook tracked user activity beyond Facebook-owned platforms.

Sen. Harris also demanded to know why the company did not inform users in 2015 that their data had been shared with Cambridge Analytica.

But on multiple occasions, it seemed like lawmakers were simply asking Zuckerberg how Facebook worked.

Several questions displayed an ignorance about the very basics of the platform and its business model.

“How do you sustain a business model in which users don’t pay for your service?” Sen. Orrin Hatch asked.

“Senator, we run ads,” Zuckerberg replied.

“How many data categories do you store, does Facebook store, on the categories that you collect?” Sen. Deb Fischer asked.

“Senator, can you clarify what you mean by data categories?” said the Facebook CEO. “I’m not actually sure what that is referring to.”

In one of the most memorable exchanges, Sen. John Kennedy began by telling Zuckerberg that Facebook’s user agreement “sucked,” then listed off a number of steps Facebook should take to improve data privacy — only to be repeatedly told by Zuckerberg that those measures were already in place.

Kennedy: “Are you willing to go back and work on giving me a greater right to erase my data?”

Zuckerberg: “Senator, you can already delete any of the data that’s there or delete all of your data.”

Kennedy: “Are you willing to expand my right to prohibit you from sharing my data?”

Zuckerberg: “Senator, again, I believe that you already have that control….”

Kennedy: “Are you willing to give me the right to take my data on Facebook and move it to another social media platform?”

Zuckerberg: “Senator, you can already do that….”

The Senators’ lack of understanding allowed Zuckerberg to evade important, unanswered questions about the extent of Facebook’s data monitoring and why the company hasn’t been more transparent with users how their data is used and how it’s been abused.

Their questions also lacked focus. They ranged from issues like Russian meddling in the 2016 campaign to hate speech to a lack of transparency in election advertising — all issues that have plagued Facebook in recent months, but all disparate problems that require different solutions.

 

Tags:

facebook Mark Zuckerberg Cambridge Analytica

Want to send us a story? Submit on Wananchi Reporting on the Citizen Digital App or Send an email to wananchi@royalmedia.co.ke or Send an SMS to 25170 or WhatsApp on 0743570000

Leave a Comment

Comments

No comments yet.

latest stories